Critics

These are suggestions for questions that you could address:

• Is the title clear and appropriate?
• Is the abstract representative of the content of the article?
• Is the purpose of the article clear?
• Are there any errors?
• Are the references relevent?
• Is the work described in sufficient detail to enable replication?
• Is the author objective in the discussion?
• What are the underlying assumptions in the work?
• Is the study appropriately designed?